Sunday, January 28, 2018

Prime Minister cannot punish.


The Prime Minister Narendra Modi said, "The youth of India is unable to tolerate corruption and we are committed to uprooting the evil of corruption from our society. It does not matter how much power one has, if someone is corrupt he or she will be punished."

Mr.Prime Minister, but how?

How do you punish the corrupt person?

And you couldn't forget Jayalalitha; in your statement, you did include the gender.

"if someone is corrupt, he or she will be punished."

The question is, How do you punish the corrupt he or she?

Do you directly punish the corrupt he or she?

Or, do you plan to introduce any new legislature to punish the corrupt he or she?

Or do you write the judgment and ask the judges to deliver your judgement?

In Saudi Arabia, the punishment is different.

In China, the punishment is different.

In United States, the President cannot punish any criminals directly.

In India, the Prime Minister Narendra Modi says, "the corrupt person, he or she will be punished (by me)"

If you change the passive voice into active voice; here is the statement:

The Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi says, "I will punish the corrupt person he or she."

It is obvious that the Prime Minister Narendra Modi forgets the following facts:

  • India is still a democracy
  • India follows the British model
  • The Prime Minister is just another Member of Parliament
  • In democracy, only the Judicial Branch could punish.
  • In the British model of Democracy, it is a number game.
Ideally, the Prime Minister could have make the statement such as,


"The youth of India is unable to tolerate corruption and we are committed to uprooting the evil of corruption from our society. It does not matter how much power one has, if someone is corrupt he or she will be punished brought to justice."

Lalu Prasad Yadav is in jail now. Who did punish Lalu?

Mr. Prime Minister, did you punish Lalu Prasad Yadav? or the court?

or, did you prepare the judgement and ask the Judges to deliver it.

Did you punish Sasikala, Mr. Prime Minister Narendra Modi? or the court?

How did you punish the corrupt Jayalalitha?


As the Prime Minister, Narendra Modi doesn't have any authority to punish any he or she. Could someone from BJP or RSS educate the Prime Minister Narendra Modi about the Constitution and Democracy.

In Democracy, you could bring the corrupt he or she to Justice and let the Judges do their job.

Mr. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, stay away from the Judicial Branch.

Mr. Narendra Modi, the fact is, you are one of the 543 Member of Parliament. All Member of Parliament are equal and in no way you are different from others, as per the current Constitution.

As a Member of Parliament, Mr. Narendra Modi, you are part of the Legislative Branch.

Yes; it is confusing; but that is the truth.
As the Prime Minister, you are burdened with Executive Responsibility.
But, as the Prime Minister, you don't have stability as the Executive President.
As per the constitution, a Member of Legislative cannot punish any citizen of India.
As the member of the Legislative Branch, you could author strict laws; but no punishment.

The Judicial Branch will interpret the law and punish the criminals.

Mr. Prime Minister, the social media is open to the global public. Before it is seen by the world, could you modify your tweet. Let it be:

The Prime Minister Narendra Modi said, "The youth of India is unable to tolerate corruption and we are committed to uprooting the evil of corruption from our society. It does not matter how much power one has, if someone is corrupt he or she will be punished brought to justice."

No comments:

Post a Comment